This study of two Toronto supportive housing buildings for people with mental illness, many of whom were previously homeless, showed that supportive housing does not negatively impact property values nor increase crime. In fact, property values increased and crime decreased during the study period. Supportive housing tenants also contribute positively to their neighbourhoods through modest support for local business and contributions to neighbourhood actions and vibrancy. The report also makes a series of policy recommendations and outlines the challenges and opportunities for supportive housing policy in Toronto.